I liked his approach, and how I was seen almost immediately. Very efficient and provided the information I was seeking
Very to the point and explains everything wonderfully
Dr Magill has been great throughout surgery, hospital visits and office visit today. Really listens and answers thoroughly. Highly recommend him,
Very easy to talk to.
Did a good job so far, kept my family informed
Experience - listens - great supporting colleagues
Excellent surgeon
He was funny and very nice
He did a great job with my surgeries.
very caring and easy to talk to along with being knowledgeable
I love him he's awesome DR. He's listen to what you say and care about you.
He’s very knowledgeable, and pleasant and helped me.
Excellent surgeon Highly recommend
Very warm. Understanding of my needs and goals
Didn't recommend surgery. Starting with PT.
He took the time to explain everything going on with me and put me at ease.
Knowledgeable, friendly, explained things well
Same as above plus he took enough time for communicating.
Very nice man
I think he is a good surgeon and a caring doctor
Dr. Magill is the best. So thorough and patient. Explains things well and goes the extra mile. Lori, his assistant, is excellent and treats patients with special care.
Dr. Magill did a fantastic job and I'm progressing much faster than expected. He's very personable and answers all my questions.
He’s great and he listens to what I have to say……have already recommended him to my sister .
I love this doctor he knows what he's doing i tell my family and friends about him.
Dr Magill is very pleasant, and answered all my questions in terms I could understand.
Answers all questions, very friendly, compassionate. As is the staff.
He was very nice and knowledgeable.
He is a very caring and compassionate person. He makes the visits easy and reassuring.
Nice person and knowledgeable
He did root repair surgery on my meniscus a year ago in July. I healed nicely. He knows what he's doing and is an excellent and caring doctor.
3rd times a charm...2011, 2023, and now 2025....shoulder surgeries. Has always been good to me thru the years and definately refer him. We laughed, said we need to work on another area...give my shoulders a brake! Haha
He is a very thorough physician.
He always explains what is going on and what solutions and options are available.
He's very kind and patient as well as thorough.
Attentive to his patients
Dr. Magill very personable and explained entire surgery and what to expect during recovery. Very patient with Mom understanding her dementia and level of understanding and repeated questions.
He is good, caring kind doctor
Very professional, personable, and knowledgeable.
He listens to his patients.
He was recommended to me
I trust him!!
He was wonderful and really explained everything to me
I love my surgeon however the pain from this surgery is alive and well and not controlled
Good Dr
Quality of work and understanding of the physical needs of the patient.
He answered all my questions and gave me a lot of information about my injury
Takes time to explain options and treatments.
He was super quick, blunt, helpful, and such a great listener. He listened to everything I had to say, gave me great feedback, and did his job very swiftly and to the point.
Only one that covered knees.
He was great
My husband recommended him and he's great
Great work and practise
Answered all questions and to the point.
He ask the right question and he was fast at getting to me before I finished the signature paperwork it went bam bam🤗
He is very informative on what he is going to do,towards the operation. Which I like. He is just a very great Dr.
Dr Magill, he actually listened to me and answered my questions…….don't find that much anymore, usually an in and out visit, a hi and goodbye but he actually took the time to make me feel that I had made the right choice in finding a new Orthopedic Doctor…… Thank you Dr. Magill !
Everyone at Emergency Room told me he is good and he has been easy to work with.
He did my left arm 2011, right arm 2023...now hurt my left again. I Trust in Dr. Magill full heartedly in helping me. Love his calmness.
He awesome
Gave me honest answers. Persanable
He is attentive and knowledgeable.
Awesome bed side manners
He was attentive and professional with me as a patient
Dr Magill is very knowledgeable and caring
VA sent me to Dr. Tom for treatment of my right knee. I had torn the meniscus in 2013. Dr. Tom establishes a good rapport with the patient, with great professional care. In my particular case, he discovered in me a somewhat rare condition: my severely arthritic hip referred pain to my knee. He referred me to Dr. Hartson in the same office. A new hip joint fixed the knee problem. Hurray! So glad to get past years of chronic pain.
Happy with Dt
He helped me before with a sore elbow. He is super nice and intelligent!
Doctor listened to me. Included me in treatment decisions. Knowledgeable.
Dr. Thomas McGill is an excellent orthopedic surgeon! He knows his stuff! Took care of a knee issue in the past & is monitoring my rotator cuff surgery, taking the time to discuss current procedure and future therapy when needed. Staff is equally helpful!
Dr. Magill did an excellent job explaining the results of the multiple x-rays. He was very good about answering questions, giving me next steps and options. First doctor in a long time that I thought actually listened to what my medical condition/issue was.
I love Dr Magill. He's a great surgeon he has a great bedside manner and for me questions that I asked him he actually answered the question he didn't get he didn't beat around the bush he said if that happens then this will happen I like that from Dr Magill.
good care
friendly , listened, took us in at a moments notice.
Knowledgeable
Dr. Magill, has been my Ortho doctor since 2012 and I would follow him to whatever location he is practicing in. I have referred friends and family to Dr. Magill and they ALL have been very happy with the care he gives his patients.
He was understanding of my condition.
Dr. Magill has an excellent reputation and has been wonderful to explain things as I have had questions. I feel that he has my best interest, and he has been supportive, which means a lot.
Dr. Magill establishes a good rapport with the patient.
Dr. Magill and the whole team was very good to me. I highly recommend him they had some of the best attitudes I’ve ever seen good group of people thank you very much.
He is compassionate, knowledgeable, addressed concerns and answered all my questions. Dr. Magil has a reputation for being the best in his field. I trust his judgment and will follow his advice.
professionalism
Dr magill and staff were very nice and caring
See above. Dr. Magill took time to listen to me. And he explained my options. And gave me guidance. And Lori took over to schedule my needs. Plus the others in the office are so nice from reception to when I left.
The tau symbol represents physicians who are employees of the Franciscan Physician Network, a division of Franciscan Alliance, Inc. All other physicians are independent members of the Medical Staff who choose to practice at a Franciscan Health hospital.
