Dismiss Modal
Franciscan Health logo
Tobi J Reidy, DO

Tobi J Reidy, DO

Colon & Rectal Surgery, Surgery
Franciscan Physician Network
Languages Spoken
English

The tau symbol represents physicians who are employees of the Franciscan Physician Network, a division of Franciscan Alliance, Inc. All other physicians are independent members of the Medical Staff who choose to practice at a Franciscan Health hospital.

accepting new patients

Franciscan Physician Network Indiana Colon & Rectal Specialists Indianapolis

5255 E. Stop 11 Road
Suite 250
Indianapolis, IN 46237

View hours
Monday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Tuesday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Wednesday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Thursday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Friday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Franciscan Physician Network Indiana Colon & Rectal Specialists Indianapolis

Franciscan Health Indianapolis

8111 South Emerson Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46237

View hours
Sunday
Open 24 hours
Monday
Open 24 hours
Tuesday
Open 24 hours
Wednesday
Open 24 hours
Thursday
Open 24 hours
Friday
Open 24 hours
Saturday
Open 24 hours
Franciscan Health Indianapolis

Franciscan Health Mooresville

1201 Hadley Road
Mooresville, IN 46158

View hours
Sunday
Open 24 hours
Monday
Open 24 hours
Tuesday
Open 24 hours
Wednesday
Open 24 hours
Thursday
Open 24 hours
Friday
Open 24 hours
Saturday
Open 24 hours
Franciscan Health Mooresville

About Me

Education

Medical School:
Nova Southeastern University

Residency:
Jewish Hospital of Cincinnati

Board Certifications

American Board of Colon & Rectal Surgery

American Board of Surgery

Video

Insurances Accepted

  • Aetna
  • Anthem
  • Anthem HIP
  • Anthem Medicaid
  • CareSource
  • Cigna Health Plans
  • Cofinity
  • Corvel
  • Department of Labor
  • Devoted Health
  • Encore Health Network
  • Humana
  • Humana Medicaid
  • Managed Health Services
  • Managed Health Services MarketPlace
  • MDWise
  • Medicaid IN
  • Medicare IN
  • Medicare Rail Road
  • MultiPlan/PHCS
  • Sagamore
  • SIHO
  • Tricare/Humana Military
  • United Health Care
  • United Health Care Medicaid
Show more

Provider Blogs

Diverticulosis: A Scary Word, But A Manageable Condition

Diverticulosis: A Scary Word, But A Manageable Condition

Read More

Podcasts

 

Provider Ratings

5 out of 5

(270 ratings)

The Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to the care provider related questions shown below from our survey. Patients that are treated in outpatient or hospital environments may receive different surveys, and the volume of responses will vary by question.

192 Reviews

11/21/2025

Very knowledgeable and friendly

11/20/2025

Dr. Reidy is not only a gifted doctor and surgeon but a genuinely compassionate human being who can tackle the presentation and solution of a medical condition in a very calming manner. Angie is fantastic and has a vast knowledge of the procedures.....she rocks!

11/18/2025

Wonderful Doctor!!

11/18/2025

I was impressed with her how she took as much time that I needed to understand what was going on and told me I did not need surgery to remove hemorrhoids.

11/18/2025

Dr Reidy is very thorough in explaining procedures and takes time to explain in detail if necessary and her bedside interaction is one of the best I’ve had

11/17/2025

She was very patient focused, compassionate, smart. Easy to talk to. Good listener.

11/16/2025

She is a kind, thoughtful and caring person!!

11/16/2025

She’s very knowledgeable and easy to work with

11/14/2025

Felt very comfortable confident put my health care in her care

11/14/2025

I trust Dr Reidy and she is always positive, friendly and answers all of my questions.

11/13/2025

As I mentioned above, she’s the best. Always explains everything thoroughly and makes me feel like she is truly concerned about me and my issues.

11/13/2025

She is an amazing Dr. I’m so glad I found her

11/06/2025

Very caring

10/28/2025

Results

10/27/2025

Makes sure you understand what’s going on and what needs to be done. Caring attitude shines through

10/25/2025

Dr Reidy is an amazing doctor! Professsional, kind, personal, and gentle.

10/24/2025

She is the BEST

10/22/2025

She was very professional and explained every step

10/22/2025

Tobi Reidy is so so nice and that woman knows her stuff. She is very informative and I feel I can talk to her without embarrassment. She is just the best!!

10/22/2025

No dought about it!

10/21/2025

True professional

10/21/2025

She was wonderful. She took time to listen to the issues I was experiencing. She was excellent at problem-solving and helping me. Very caring. Very informative. Excellent care.

10/19/2025

She is the best !!!

10/17/2025

Dr. Reidy to your concerns. She answers all your questions and/or concerns and she is tremendously focused on making sure her patients understand the answers to those questions or concerns. If you need a procedure, she explains it so you can understand what's happening in plain English. I always feel peaceful knowing she truly cares for what's going on with my body medically.

10/17/2025

Dr. Reidy is low key and So Funny! Her jokes relaxs you to the point that you almost forget why you are their 😁

10/09/2025

She is very easy to talk to!

10/09/2025

:-)

10/08/2025

She was Fantastic!!

10/04/2025

Great dr. Very good listener.

09/29/2025

Tobi is an excellent doctor, surgeon and people person.

09/25/2025

talks to you and explains everything

09/24/2025

So compassionate, down to earth, knowledgeable, easy to talk to, respectful

09/24/2025

Amazing Dr. that communicates and truly cares. Again, very rare.

09/23/2025

She is wonderful. I have been under her care since 2015.

09/22/2025

Very polite and professional.

09/18/2025

Detail oriented. Caring about my issues. Gave me info. Positive

09/18/2025

excellent explanations and takes all the time needed.

09/18/2025

Very thorough and compassionate

09/16/2025

Words cannot describe how she is a very kind, compassionate and even more an awesome doctor. I traveled more than 2200 miles for her and would do it again.

09/16/2025

No problems

09/15/2025

She is an absolutely amazing Dr

09/14/2025

I could not express deeply enough the amount of compassion she demonstrated in my appointment.

09/11/2025

She is a great person and Doctor . She really cares for her patients and she listens to you.

09/09/2025

As stated above very easy to understand the issues

09/03/2025

Because she is very friendly and kind,she truly cares about your problem. She takes the time to listen and then works on a solution.

09/02/2025

As I said above Tobi Reidy is the best. I trust her.

09/02/2025

Very nice

09/02/2025

Reidy tell it like it is

08/30/2025

Dr. Reidy is just a wonderful person. She told me everything that was going to happen and had me well prepared for the after surgery care

08/28/2025

See above. Also Dr. Reidy has a good sense of humor.

08/27/2025

Great Doctor. Very understanding and very knowledgeable.

08/24/2025

Was impressed with her knowledge, directness and friendly demeanor. Very approachable. She obviously loves what she does.

08/23/2025

She’s thorough, super smart, compassionate, engaged, and charming.

08/23/2025

Dr. Reidy was amazing, she made me feel very comfortable. Explained everything where I could understand and asked me several times if I had any questions.

08/21/2025

She is so thorough. Great communicator.

08/20/2025

Dr. Reidy made sure to explain the process.

08/18/2025

Best bedside manner for tough subject

08/15/2025

She was very friendly, knowledgeable, and explained procedures very well. She took time with us and answered all questions. Offered some treatment options that had not been presented to us before.

08/14/2025

Dr Reidy explained every step of surgery and recovery. She is a fantastic surgeon as well as a wonderful person. She removed part of my colon, and I have recovered nicely. I am clear and no need for chemo or radiation.

08/13/2025

Very clear and concise information. Great bedside manner for relieving anxiety.

08/06/2025

She was kind, knowledgeable and made me feel comfortable in an uncomfortable situation.

08/04/2025

Extremely nice, great bedside manner and knowledgeable. Explains in depth any questions you have and makes sure you understand. Always a smile on her face

08/03/2025

Dr Riedy has saved my life,and now more surgery is required,so she tells you like it is,so you know going in what is going to happen ,she is the best.

07/31/2025

Caring and thorough

07/29/2025

She is the best of the best. Very kind, caring, and takes her time to answer all of your questions and concerns.

07/27/2025

I have 9 doctors. Dr. Reidy, I trust completely. She is a very caring person. Her whole team is excellent.

07/23/2025

She is professional, competent, and compassionate. She makes her patients feel comfortable.

07/23/2025

She’s compassionate, she knows her profession and answers all your questions, she’s patient. And just has a phenomenal bedside manner

07/17/2025

Great professional skills. Great bedside manner, Great Sense of humor. Tells you the facts and explains things, procedures, and issues very well.

07/17/2025

Very thoughro. Told me of my surgical possibilities but not to be certain until tests and scans completed Should empathy and sincerity for my current circumstances.

07/17/2025

Dr. Reidy genuinely connects with patients.

07/12/2025

Dr reidy listen and explains everything very clearly.

07/11/2025

She’s brilliant, and extremely kind.

07/11/2025

Very professional and answers questions and explains everything

07/09/2025

Dr, Reidy is the best, she is an excellent, caring doctor. She is extremely knowledgeable and she always takes time to explain everything and answer all of my questions.

07/09/2025

Extremely knowledgeable, great communication skills, puts patients at ease and instills confidence.

07/06/2025

She is through

06/19/2025

Always remembers me and answers all my questions. I have complete confidence in her ability and the care she provides.

06/17/2025

Helped me ease my anxiety

06/06/2025

Very friendly and always cheerful!!!

06/04/2025

Dr. Reidy takes time to explain things to me in a way I can understand. I never feel rushed.

06/03/2025

Amazing bedside manner.

06/02/2025

She is so friendly. It’s like talking to your family. She’s very sympathetic.

05/30/2025

Knowledgeable, personable, down to earth

05/30/2025

On time. interested

05/29/2025

Dr. Reidy is an exceptional physician with a truly outstanding bedside manner. From the moment I met her, she made me feel at ease with her calm, compassionate approach. She takes the time to thoroughly explain every aspect of the diagnosis and treatment options in a way that is easy to understand, which gave me great confidence in my care. Her professionalism, warmth, and attention to detail are truly appreciated. I highly recommend Dr. Reidy to anyone seeking a knowledgeable and empathetic colorectal surgeon.

05/29/2025

She is always up on current therapies and able to answer all my questions and provides excellent care.

05/28/2025

Knowledge

05/28/2025

Dr Reidy she's wonderful

05/28/2025

Great bedside demeanor, helpful and down to earth discussing issues.

05/28/2025

I can't say enough about what a wonderful caring doctor that Dr. Reidy is. she is compassionate, a excellent listener, and teacher. I am blessed to have found her, and to be her patient!

05/21/2025

Dr Reidy is so kind and knowledgeable.

05/19/2025

Knowledgeable staff

05/19/2025

She is personable, caring and super knowledgeable.

05/14/2025

Thought she was good and frank with a touch of humor.

05/13/2025

She is very thorough in giving the patient information about surgery and what was done. I really like her.

05/12/2025

Dr Reidy is knowledgable and has a very good bed side manner.

05/12/2025

So personable !

05/08/2025

She made what could have been an awkward meeting into a comfortable meetings. Age is exceptionally thorough and caring and took the needed time to answer my questions

05/08/2025

She is a great doctor!

05/07/2025

Dr Reidy is very caring and knowledgeable in her field. She doesn't give up when addressing your health related issues. She is very personable, with an excellent bedside manner.

05/07/2025

Dr. Reidy is friendly, caring and takes the time to explain everything to make informed decisions. She is an excellent surgeon.

05/06/2025

She's kind. She explained things in easy terms. She cares with compassion.

05/06/2025

Very thoughtful and understanding

05/06/2025

She made feel very comfortable

05/03/2025

She was extremely thorough, explained things very well, gave options, and wasn’t pushy at all

05/03/2025

Dr. Reidy is a fantastic Doctor

05/01/2025

Very good too the point and answered all my questions

04/29/2025

Dr Reidy is the best of all. She was absolutely the best Dr I’ve ever had

04/28/2025

Dr. Reidy explains everything and makes you feel at ease, even with the embarrassing examination. I felt free to ask questions and I did not feel rushed. She is such a nice person that it makes you want to come back to see her.

04/23/2025

Really liked her, she made you feel very at ease.

04/23/2025

She is the best.

04/23/2025

Dr. Reidy has been wonderful. She has a very kind and approachable presence that makes me feel comfortable, no matter if it’s asking questions or voicing my concerns and fears. She has a way of lightening the mood and easing my anxiety over health issues that I’ve been dealing with for years. I am grateful to have found her.

04/23/2025

Dr. Reidy is top notch and has taken care of me every time, always listening to my needs and explaining in a way even I can understand

04/23/2025

Loved her….very knowledgeable about her profession

04/22/2025

Knowledgeable and caring doctor .

04/08/2025

She fantastic in every aspect.

04/05/2025

She’s thorough and personable

04/04/2025

I feel like they stay on top of a situation. If I have any concerns I feel comfortable contacting them.

04/03/2025

Tobi Reidy is the best Dr. Hands down she makes me so comfortable.

04/02/2025

She is personable and know her field 100%

04/01/2025

Very nice and polite

04/01/2025

She's the BEST!

04/01/2025

Dr. Reidy was very professional and personable. I felt very comfortable with her and her advice with how to proceed with the diagnosis of my medical condition.

04/01/2025

Given the uncomfortable nature of the visit, I was treated with compassion and respect.

03/31/2025

She listens. Very professional but approachable as well.

03/29/2025

She is too good to be true. Above and Beyond what I expected. I can’t say enough good about her expertise her compassion and her professionalism.

03/27/2025

She made me feel so comfortable and seemed to genuinely care

03/27/2025

Dr. Reidy is the best of the best. Compassionate, wise, and caring.

03/26/2025

Dr. Reidy impressed me as very knowledgeable about the subject of CRC. She was very personable and seemed personally concerned about my particular case. She took the time to answer all our questions and educate us on CRC subject. I feel like I'm in the hands of the best of the best.

03/26/2025

Dr. Reidy is a real person who talks to you like you are an important person. She takes time to explain procedures and tests in easy to understand language.

03/25/2025

GREAT, GREAT, Dr!! Very friendly, informative and takes her time with you to discuss situations and makes sure you understand everything!

03/25/2025

She is top of her field! She is giving the help I need where other doctors have failed.

03/25/2025

She's incredible Doctor and doesn't talk over your head.

03/24/2025

She is an excellent surgeon who also cares about her patients and knows how to talk to them.

03/23/2025

Tobi Reidy is truly amazing! I couldn't ask for a better doctor. She did my surgery and I was so well informed before the procedure. Being prepared made my recovery great. I can not recommend her enough!

03/20/2025

She is upbeat! She explains procedures when and she takes her time to make sure you understand

03/20/2025

Dr Reidy can never retire!!

03/14/2025

Dr. Reidy shares her knowledge of a situation in plain English. Her support and expertise helped me through a chronic issue to achieve a good outcome.

03/13/2025

Compassion, knowledge and skill that is off the charts

03/13/2025

She gives you all the truths regarding your situation.

03/13/2025

If i trust her I would trust her with my family and friends. And i do trust her.

03/12/2025

Dr Reidy is the best. She explains everything about the procedure and has a calming effect on the patient.

03/08/2025

She’s great. Skilled surgeon, good bedside manner and listening skills. Makes you feel like she is giving you her undivided attention.

03/04/2025

Dr Reidy was so kind. She listened to me and took her time explaining my condition to me.

03/04/2025

Friendly, caring answer all questions

03/04/2025

I saw Dr. Reidy regarding surgery for reconnecting my colon. I now have an ostomy. She is very thorough and explained everything for me. I feel very confident in her knowledge and ability. Also her P.A. was very helpful.

02/26/2025

Compassionate and caring Explanation very good

02/26/2025

She is wonderful. Made me feel at ease, took the time to explain what was going on, drew a picture and was warm and genuine

02/25/2025

A helpfull and caring doctor

02/18/2025

She is very caring but no-nonsense, she tells you the truth and helps you work through the tough stuff. I couldn't wish for a better surgeon. Amazing team.

02/17/2025

Her knowledge is top shelf.

02/12/2025

Dr. Reidy was thorough and thoughtful. Very kind.

02/11/2025

Dr.Reidy cares for her patients, listens well and is prompt.

02/06/2025

She is caring and knowledgeable. I trust her care.

02/05/2025

She is attentive, explains things very well, does not rush discussions

02/04/2025

Dr. Reidy is a huge blessing. I'm very thankful for her. She listened to my concerns and took the initiative to ensure I had a plan for care before I left. I have so much trust in her and I'm truly glad she's a part of my care team.

01/30/2025

Dr. Ready is a wonderful doctor that takes the time to listen to the patient’s concerns and explain the process.

01/30/2025

She is awesome

01/30/2025

Dr. Reidy is an outstanding doctor who stays current on the most recent medical treatments in her field. She also has outstanding communication and listening skills.

01/28/2025

Excellent care giver!!

01/28/2025

See above response. I feel she is very thorough and I have confidence in her. Also my GP recommended her.

01/27/2025

She was very courteous, patient and helpful. She was polite and easy to understand when she spoke and explained the situation that I am going through. She was through with her explanation and answered my questions in understandable terms.

01/24/2025

Very honest and thorough with results

01/22/2025

she is the best

01/22/2025

Doc Reidy was awesome. She has a very calming and friendly demeanor. She was gentle and talked me thru everything she was doing. She distracted me with questions while I was in an uncomfortable part of my appointment and even made me laugh. She was very informative, answered all my questions and she eased my nervousness.

01/16/2025

Very friendly and knowledgeable

01/16/2025

might be completely healed, no surgery needed

01/15/2025

Besides being extremely knowledgeable she is sensitive, compassionate and positive.

01/15/2025

Her knowledge and bed side manner

01/14/2025

Personable, easy to talk to, comforting, honest

01/12/2025

Dr Reidy is awesome. She really made us feel seen and heard. Took the time to to make sure we understood everything that was taking place with a clear path to what’s next.

01/09/2025

Dr. Reidy has an amazing bedside manner. Even when having hard conversations, you feel safe and trust that she genuinely has your best interest at heart. If feels like you are talking to a peer so there is no Us vs Them feeling. She takes the time to explain medical information on the level necessary for your comprehension (even drawing diagrams for us visual learners). I cannot stress enough how positive my experience with this office has been.

01/08/2025

Dr Reidy, was skilled, helpful and explained everything to make sure I understood the issues and the solutions. Even though she is extremely busy, she made me feel as if I was the most important person.

01/08/2025

Very personable, took extra time to discuss details in depth. I feel like my concerns were adddressed properly and very efficiently. Thanks!

01/08/2025

She’s the best!

01/04/2025

Again her staff was friendly, helpful and informative

01/02/2025

She's a sweetheart.. And she cares about you

01/02/2025

She has small hands. Very important in a rectal surgeon.

12/24/2024

Dr. Tobi Reidy is amazing!!! She is an awesome listener and thoughtful care taker!!!

12/23/2024

Dr Reidy is the Best

12/17/2024

Top performing Doctor!!

12/16/2024

Very good, the best.

12/11/2024

She's the best of the best. Through and listens to you concerns.

12/10/2024

Professional, friendly, I felt confident and comfortable during out interaction.

12/05/2024

Toby Reid is a, very good doctor and she sits down and CARES. She explains everything to you on a one-on-one.

12/04/2024

Personal care, she listens and provides care for you

12/02/2024

Friendly & knowledgeable provider

12/02/2024

Dr. Reidy and the staff have been tremendous. Dr. Reidy is professional, concise, and informative and I know I am in good hands. I wouldn’t recommend any other doctor.

11/30/2024

Knowledge

11/30/2024

Same as before. Courteous, reliable, caring

11/29/2024

She listens and thinks. She doesn't jump to conclusions. She's appreciative and genuinely concerned. Since 2019, I have been with both my mom and my sister (oncology appointments) and neither have received the level of care and concern that I had with just this one visit from their doctor. She doesn't try to pretend she knows things. She listens and goes from there.
Show more

Hospitals