Dismiss Modal
Franciscan Health logo
Natalya Mather, MD

Natalya Mather, MD

Family Medicine
Franciscan Physician Network
Languages Spoken
English, Russian

The tau symbol represents physicians who are employees of the Franciscan Physician Network, a division of Franciscan Alliance, Inc. All other physicians are independent members of the Medical Staff who choose to practice at a Franciscan Health hospital.

accepting new patients

Franciscan Physician Network Franklin Township Family Medicine

8325 E. Southport Road
Suite 100
Indianapolis, IN 46259

View hours
Monday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Tuesday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Wednesday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Thursday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Friday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Franciscan Physician Network Franklin Township Family Medicine

Franciscan Health Indianapolis

8111 South Emerson Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46237

View hours
Sunday
Open 24 hours
Monday
Open 24 hours
Tuesday
Open 24 hours
Wednesday
Open 24 hours
Thursday
Open 24 hours
Friday
Open 24 hours
Saturday
Open 24 hours
Franciscan Health Indianapolis

About Me

Education

Medical School:
Indiana University School of Medicine

Internship:
Franciscan Health Olympia Fields Rotating Internship

Residency:
Franciscan Health Family Medicine Residency

Board Certifications

American Board of Family Medicine

Video

Insurances Accepted

  • Aetna
  • Anthem
  • Anthem HIP
  • Anthem Medicaid
  • CareSource
  • Cigna Health Plans
  • Cofinity
  • Corvel
  • Department of Labor
  • Devoted Health
  • Encore Health Network
  • Humana
  • Humana Medicaid
  • Managed Health Services
  • Managed Health Services MarketPlace
  • Medicaid IN
  • Medicare IN
  • Medicare Rail Road
  • MultiPlan/PHCS
  • Sagamore
  • SIHO
  • Tricare/Humana Military
  • United Health Care
  • United Health Care Medicaid
Show more

Provider Ratings

4.9 out of 5

(223 ratings)

The Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to the care provider related questions shown below from our survey. Patients that are treated in outpatient or hospital environments may receive different surveys, and the volume of responses will vary by question.

143 Reviews

11/18/2025

Caring, prompt, explain thing in a way I can understand

11/18/2025

She is always very thorough and has given me confidence in her abilities.

11/13/2025

She takes time to listen to my concerns and explains everything to me. She is a cheerleader in my progress towards weight loss and a healthier life style.

11/10/2025

Great first impression. Caring and professional.

11/06/2025

Professional, kind, educated me in areas of necessity. A wise caring Doctor. Patient with my decisions.

11/04/2025

Dr. Mather was professional, did not hurry though my patient visit. Made timely appointments. Very nice friendly manner.

11/03/2025

Very professional and thorough

10/29/2025

I really like her

10/29/2025

knowledgeable kind good communication skills helpful

10/28/2025

Dr Natalya seemed a bit snippy today

10/27/2025

She was willing to give me extra time to accomplish Medicare visit. I never feel rushed by her

10/23/2025

Very professional woman and very strong on advice..(which I personally like, no beating around the bush)

10/23/2025

I pleased with the time she takes and her thorough friendly approach. Very knowledgeable.

10/21/2025

Dr Mather was recommended to me by my sister in law, and I would be honored to and HAVE actually recommended her to my friends.

10/21/2025

She is very thorough and is interested in holistic preventative medicine.

10/19/2025

She listens, ask questions if needed to completely understand my questions and gives insightful information and suggestions.

10/14/2025

She explains everything to me very clear

10/13/2025

She is very thorough

10/08/2025

She took her time to listen to my concerns, explained issues I have and seemed sincerely concerned.

10/07/2025

Professional, efficient, clear instructions

10/07/2025

Very knowledgeable and easy to talk with about health issues.

10/04/2025

She listened as I described my symptoms, prescribed the needed medication, and encouraged me to contact her again if my condition did not improve. I felt that she cares about her patients.

10/03/2025

Love Dr Mather. Very thorough and she listens to her patients.

10/03/2025

Very efficient

10/02/2025

Dr. Mather is thorough with her examinations for a proper diagnosis and treatment plan. She takes the time to listen to my explanations on what ails me in order to provide a good prognosis.

09/30/2025

Dr. Mather is very thorough and an excellent listener. She never rushes through an appointment.

09/25/2025

She is very friendly and professional and a good listener.

09/24/2025

Dr Mather had a very warm and comforting demeanor and made me feel very comfortable during my first exam. My previous PCP retired and I was reluctantly searching for a new Dr. Dr Mather was wonderful and took her time as we covered my medical history and concerns.

09/23/2025

She spends time and listens

09/20/2025

A very compassionate doctor.

09/10/2025

She was wonderful, a great listner, explained things I could understand

09/09/2025

Very friendly helpful and knowledgeable

09/08/2025

Seemed knowledgeable.

09/07/2025

She is very welcoming and helpful

09/06/2025

Because she is a great Doctor

09/02/2025

She was fantastic. She listened to my concerns, and genuinely seemed to care. Dr. Mather’s plan to address my issues seemed ideal.

09/02/2025

I’ve been employed with St Francis for over 15 years. She is by far the best one I’ve seen over the years. She takes time to listen to your concerns and explains everything to you.

08/31/2025

no friendly no bedside manner

08/25/2025

She was informative, took her time with us. Answered all of our question

08/23/2025

Covered a lot of topics. She is proactive not reactive.

08/22/2025

Dr Mather is very thorough

08/21/2025

She is amazing and really listens to my concerns and spends a great deal of time at each visit!

08/21/2025

Knowledgeable and professional

08/20/2025

She is compassionate, smart and listens to your comcerns. She follows up when needed. She is open to hearing and doing tests that appropriate to related symptoms. I have had a very long year of 2 undiagnosed symptoms but it is not because she has not tried and sent the right referrals. I am very thankful for her.

08/19/2025

Thorough and pleasant

08/17/2025

She is a patient and effective doctor who takes the time to listen.

08/11/2025

I had not previously met Dr Mather. She was confident and able to answer my critical questions. I have loved and felt Dr Hekman has been an outstanding doctor for me. Dr Mather confirmed my assurance this medical group is outstanding in every way. Her nurse was extremely detailed in updating my patient information that recently changed with my recent diagnosis by Dr Jared [ ] team

08/05/2025

We really like her she is very nice and takes time with you

08/02/2025

Professional and friendly

07/31/2025

She is caring, patient, and very knowledgeable on the medical situation. Shares all of that medical knowledge with the patient.

07/29/2025

She cares about me. I'm sure she cares about all of her patients. She is thorough.

07/28/2025

Very thorough, friendly, and knowledgeable.

07/25/2025

Dr. Mather addressed ALL of my concerns, not only the ones that I had sent ahead of my visit, but additional ones that arose during my visit. I appreciate her expertise, as well as her caring and encouragement.

07/23/2025

Saw me very quick no waiting and very nice staff

07/21/2025

Her personal approach and excellent communication.

07/17/2025

I have great confidence in Dr. Mather.

07/17/2025

Professional

07/16/2025

She is my newest doctor and have had her since December 2024. Being elderly it is important to me to have a doctor that will stay on top of my changing body and medical changes. She has really taken time to listen to my concerns. Very personable and professional. Never feel rushed and working with me to take care of my medical needs. I feel confident in her decisions and that puts my mind at ease.

07/16/2025

She was understanding and got my labs set up to resolve my problem. She was pleasent and knowledgeable!

07/15/2025

Wonderful Dr. thorough and listens ask questions ask if you have any concerns let’s you know if you need her she is there

07/15/2025

She’s awesome! She listens, is honest, friendly and kind!

07/14/2025

Great Doctor!

07/13/2025

Dr. Mather is easy to talk to and takes time to address your concerns

07/13/2025

Great service

07/11/2025

I feel like she really cares about the entirety of my health.

07/08/2025

Because she is caring and listens and is gentle in her time with me. She is not harsh. She is the best doctor I have ever had!!!!

06/30/2025

She listens and recommends without judgment.

06/25/2025

She just became my new dr and she made the transition so east it’s as if I have known her for years. Very nice and very knowledgeable. Great doctor

06/23/2025

She is very caring very and spends quality time with you.

06/23/2025

She listens and explains

06/21/2025

Listens to you / Knowledgeable / Friendly / Explains things

06/21/2025

Very nice, seemed thorough and listened to concerns.

06/20/2025

I liked the way we communicated at our visit. She listens to my concerns. Next morning I received a call from Franciscan Hospital to schedule tests that she ordered. No waiting. She is on it immediately

06/17/2025

My children and I had Dr. Mather at the residency location and wanted to continue to have her as our doctor when she moved as she was our favorite. She has helped us so much in the past and listens to our concerns.

06/16/2025

Dr Mather listens to you, allows you to have input into decision-making about your healthcare plan. She personally called me when there was an issue with my lab order.

06/16/2025

She is very attentive to me and took the time I needed for my concerns.

06/11/2025

She is respectful, knowledgeable and she listens.

06/10/2025

She is thorough and extremely nice and listens to what you have to say.

06/06/2025

Dr. Mather listened intently and asked relevant questions regarding my health. I feel she answered my questions in enough detail, which was very important and helpful.

06/03/2025

Dr. Mather looks at me and talks to me when I am her patient, instead of paying more attention to what someone who is with me has to say.

06/03/2025

Dr. Mather was awesome. Asked a lot of questions and was dedicated to finding out what my issue is.

05/30/2025

As stated above takes the time to explain medical issues with you. Is very personable.

05/30/2025

Dr. Mather was very thorough and checked to see if all my needs were met. She took her time and I didn’t feel rushed at all.

05/30/2025

She’s young and thorough with her patients.

05/22/2025

So friendly and I never felt rushed like my previous doctor.

05/22/2025

I have only seen Dr. Mather twice but already feel comfortable discussing any issues with her and any communication or concerns I have sent to her on My Chart have been quickly and thoughtfully answered.

05/19/2025

Very professional and down to earth.

05/15/2025

Love, love Dr. Mather! Very personable, friendly, and knowledgeable. Took the time to address my concerns. Thank you!

05/14/2025

Very friendly, listens to you and is personal. Open to a holistic approach to health.

05/13/2025

She listens and gives me excellent advice on any problems that might come up.

05/13/2025

Friendly and informative and thorough and good philosophy

05/13/2025

She is knowledgeable, friendly and a good listener.

05/12/2025

I’m just getting to know her. I believe she is going to be a great doctor to this office.

05/12/2025

Great doctor. Very smart and common sense approach to medicine

05/05/2025

She was professional and competent.

04/30/2025

Dr Mather is my new doctor since Dr Van Gemert left. Dr Mather has been wonderful. She is caring, thorough, and easy to talk to.

04/25/2025

I am a client who feels I need to take an active part in maintaining my health. Thus, I make the time to research current medical recommendations and advancements. This was my initial visit with Dr. Mather and I was, frankly, amazed by her knowledge of new information on white matter brain disease, new medication options, nutrition and supplementation support. She raised several concerns about my health and the dosages of several of the supplements I was taking - and lab test results verified her concerns. In the simplest language, I feel safe under Dr. Mather's care.

04/25/2025

Dr Mather is really great! Personable, but to the point and I really feel like she’ll listen to me as a patient if I have any issues that need to be addressed. I am so glad I switched to her care!

04/22/2025

Listens to my concerns and needs. Dr Mather is a wonderful Doctor.

04/21/2025

See above…I have given her name to a co-worker who needs a new PCP.

04/20/2025

Dr Mather is kind and very helpful and understanding.

04/17/2025

Listens, explains, compassionate.

04/16/2025

Dr. Mather was welcoming and put me at ease. Asked questions and gave me the opportunity to explore options.

04/16/2025

She is new, but, I like her and she is thorough and honest.

04/15/2025

Concerned, knowledgable, warm and easy to. Talk to.

04/14/2025

This is only my third visit with her and today I felt really comfortable and confident that she understands my health concerns and is doing everything to help me improve my health. I just turned 78 and all of a sudden things have come up that had me stressed out. Between her and my heart doctor they are working to help correct these issues and following up to make sure all is working to my benefit. She took all the time I needed to answer questions and make recommendations.

04/12/2025

She doesn’t rush you and she listens.

04/12/2025

Thorough, excellent and great communicator’

04/07/2025

Seems to care about what's going on and listens

04/06/2025

Takes her time and listens

04/04/2025

Explained that above.

04/03/2025

She was very supportive, thorough and generally appeared to be a knowledgeable and caring doctor.

03/25/2025

She cares. She is thorough.

03/24/2025

She actually took the time to listen and helped me.

03/22/2025

She is very thorough, professional, and friendly. Explains things in terms I understand.

03/18/2025

She’s great

03/18/2025

Great!

03/14/2025

I felt heard, took my concerns seriously and explained things thoroughly without judgment .

03/11/2025

Great listener, caring, offers solutions to concerns

03/06/2025

Kind, friendly, didn’t rush.

03/04/2025

Very good listener Very knowledgeable

03/04/2025

I would certainly recommend Dr. Mather to anyone. I am extremely happy with Dr. Mather and hope I never lose her as my Doctor. She is kind, friendly, knowledgeable and takes the time to listen. Wonderful Doctor!!

02/21/2025

She's awesome. She really listens to her patients and takes the time to address issues. She has a wonderful personality and is a caring doctor.

02/18/2025

Dr Mather is very thorough and has a great personality.

02/05/2025

She is very thorough and definitely cares about the patient.

01/23/2025

This was my first meeting w/Dr. Mather as my new primary care physician. I was excited to meet her and I had heard some great things about her before our meeting. I WAS NOT disappointed. I appreciated her patient friendly (very personable) manner in which we communicated. Dr. Mather answered my questions succinctly and in a way that I could comprehend. Furthermore she made some recommendations about concerns that I had. We reviewed my comprehensive and vitamin D blood panels, but prior to my appointment the nurse called from Dr. Mather's office to let me know the results of my blood panel(s) ahead of time. No one had ever done that before. My After-Visit Summary was very thorough and I came away w/a VERY POSITIVE and confident impression of Dr. Mather as my new primary care physician.

01/16/2025

I was sad and disappointed when Dr. [ ] left to go to North Carolina, I am so glad Dr. Mather is her replacement. I feel I will get the continued care I received before.

01/16/2025

She is very knowledgeable, kind, friendly, very caring.

01/14/2025

She is very nice this was the frist time I. Was here today. So fare I like her.

01/14/2025

First time meeting Dr. Mather, my new doctor. She was very nice and didn't rush through my appointment.

01/13/2025

First time going to this doctor. She was very knowledgeable and caring.

01/07/2025

My husband and I are very happy so far with our care from Dr Mather. It has been a pleasure getting to know her.

12/29/2024

Dr. Mather is my new primary care, this was my first visit. . She took time to listen to my concerns, discuss her method off hasn't care .

12/22/2024

Very personable and spent time with me to listen to my concerns. Professional

12/21/2024

She was very attentive and took time to get to know me

12/21/2024

professional, caring care

12/19/2024

Thorough about healthcare and very likable!

12/12/2024

Seems very knowledgeable and very nice

12/11/2024

This was my first visit with her and she's wonderful. She listened to all my questions and made sure everything I needed was covered!

12/10/2024

She was wonderful. I was worried becaquse I loved Dr. VanGemert, but Dr. Mather really listened to me and my concerns. She asked questions, explained things thoroughly (some of which I had not heard before) and gave me a plan that makes me feel like we are headed in the right direction to get my health on track. She ordered tests and told me why they were important, she gave me a referral and she was just outstanding. I have already had some of the tests done and for the first time in a long time I feel like I am being proactive about my health instead of reactive. Thank you!!

12/10/2024

Dr. Mather is very personable. She listens to you and interacts well with you. She seems truly concerned with your well being.

12/07/2024

She was wonderful to me - took the time to listen in a sympathetic and concerned way. And was very professional and knowledgeable in recommending a course of treatment.

12/05/2024

She listens and discusses my concerns well and is not in a hurry, so she doesn’t miss anything.
Show more

Hospitals