Dismiss Modal
Franciscan Health logo
Donald E. McMahon, MD

Donald E. McMahon, MD

Family Medicine
Franciscan Physician Network
Languages Spoken
English

The tau symbol represents physicians who are employees of the Franciscan Physician Network, a division of Franciscan Alliance, Inc. All other physicians are independent members of the Medical Staff who choose to practice at a Franciscan Health hospital.

Franciscan Physician Network CityWay Family Medicine

426 South Alabama Street
Suite 100
Indianapolis, IN 46225

View hours
Monday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Tuesday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Wednesday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Thursday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Friday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Franciscan Physician Network CityWay Family Medicine

Franciscan Health Indianapolis

8111 South Emerson Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46237

View hours
Sunday
Open 24 hours
Monday
Open 24 hours
Tuesday
Open 24 hours
Wednesday
Open 24 hours
Thursday
Open 24 hours
Friday
Open 24 hours
Saturday
Open 24 hours
Franciscan Health Indianapolis

About Me

Education

Medical School:
Indiana University School of Medicine

Residency:
Franciscan Health Indianapolis Medical Staff Department

Undergraduate:
Indiana University Bloomington

Board Certifications

American Board of Family Medicine

Video

Insurances Accepted

  • Aetna
  • Anthem
  • Anthem HIP
  • Anthem Medicaid
  • CareSource
  • Cigna Health Plans
  • Cofinity
  • Corvel
  • Department of Labor
  • Devoted Health
  • Encore Health Network
  • Humana
  • Lutheran Preferred
  • Managed Health Services
  • Managed Health Services MarketPlace
  • Medicaid IN
  • Medicare IN
  • Medicare Rail Road
  • MultiPlan/PHCS
  • Sagamore
  • SIHO
  • Tricare/Humana Military
  • United Health Care
  • United Health Care Medicaid
Show more

Provider Ratings

5 out of 5

(173 ratings)

The Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to the care provider related questions shown below from our survey. Patients that are treated in outpatient or hospital environments may receive different surveys, and the volume of responses will vary by question.

116 Reviews

03/20/2026

Dr McMahon is great

03/19/2026

Dr. McMahon knows my health history and makes sure that I am tested in those areas I have had difficulties.

03/17/2026

He takes time to listen and very thourough diagnosis.

03/16/2026

Takes time to really listen

03/16/2026

Been seeing him since he beginning practicing. Follow him from his first office to his current office. He get to the problem of the issues instead of just trying to cover the symptoms. He's a great doctor, better then some I have visited in the network.

03/16/2026

Donald McMahon is a great doctor, he is knowledgeable, he genuinely cares about his patients, he is very attentive as to my personal issues and solutions for them. Donald makes appointments fun and serious at appropriate times when needed. I recommend that Donald gives training seminars on how to be an effective doctor.

03/13/2026

listens

03/12/2026

Very attentive and shows concern for you as an individual. Makes recommendations that are appropriate for needs/concerns.

03/10/2026

Very knowledgeable, a pleasant experience !

03/09/2026

Dr McMahon is very knowledgeable and helpful to answer my questions.

03/09/2026

Dr. McMahon is very knowledgeable and answered all my questions.

03/02/2026

I like my Dr. He listens to his patients and their concerns

02/26/2026

Dr McMahon is the kind of doctor everyone wants to have. He listens. He's compassionate. He instills confidence.

02/24/2026

Exceptional doctor.

02/24/2026

Dr. McMahon is easy to talk to and I feel that his is very concerned about my health. Never feels hurried and always gives me options for my care!

02/20/2026

He’s a down to earth doctor who takes the time with you. He’s knowledgeable, professional, smart and a very caring doctor he is the best doctor I have ever had.

02/09/2026

Dr. Donald McMahon is the best Doctor ever he cares about his patients & makes people smile & he shows he cares about his patients as well

02/03/2026

He listens and always has great recommendations to follow up on. He is a people person.

01/29/2026

He has been our physician since my son was 2 years old. He's now 36. Doctor McMahon is the best doctor in Indiana. He's almost like family, not just our doctor. I don't even want to think about him retiring we will miss him badly.I hope he sticks around for a long , long time i tell everyone what a great doctor he is in what a great place.City way is in all that works there.I now have to other family members that have doctors at city way now.Love you all

01/24/2026

He is very kind, caring & compassionate and cares about his patients. Wonderful bedside manners.I couldn't be more happier with the choice of my primay dr.He treats his patients with nothing but compassion & he takes his time to explain to you the way you can understand.

01/20/2026

He listens.

01/20/2026

Because he cares about people

01/17/2026

Dr. McMahon takes very good care of me. He’s very considerate when prescribing new medicine. He always thinks outside the box which helps.

01/15/2026

Highly competent Doctor, friendly, knowledgeable, and thoughtful.

01/14/2026

He really cares and listens.

01/13/2026

He is a smart man. I worked in ER as an RN He is smart. Kind. Compassionate.

01/13/2026

He is very personable and sincerely cares about his patients

01/13/2026

Dr. McMahon is patient, understanding and takes time to listen. I trust him with my medical care and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to others.

01/08/2026

His diagnosing, listens, and explains treatment options thoroughly.

12/27/2025

Great with people ,and a doctor who cares ,not just there to get paid!

12/26/2025

Just a great doctor with practical treatment

12/22/2025

Always an excellent care provider.

12/18/2025

Great doctor! Definitely takes his time and listens.

12/16/2025

Dr. McMahon is very easy to talk with. He explains everything very well and is very punctual with his appointments.

12/16/2025

The best

12/11/2025

Listens to me and helps me get medicine that works!

12/09/2025

Yes, because Dr. Mchmahon is the best doctor ever!!!

12/08/2025

He's always makes sure I'm in great help

12/08/2025

He is personable, knowledgeable, kind, and fun.

12/04/2025

He's been my Dr for 25+ yrs. He's cared for all of my ailments and is spot on diagnosing .

12/01/2025

Best family doctor we have ever had.

11/28/2025

🐝 with him twenty years very personable

11/24/2025

He is one of the best doctors you could ever have for your medical needs. Justin(medical assistant) is also wonderful

11/18/2025

Professional, personable, straightforward and a good listener.

11/18/2025

He's incredible. Please see my comments above.

11/15/2025

Dr McMahon is the reason I use this office. Great Doctor and a better person.

11/13/2025

Doctor McMahon doesn’t push stuff on you, he listens to you and give you options

11/12/2025

He’s the best doctor in the world

11/11/2025

Dr. McMahon is a one of a kind Doctor that listens & caters to the needs of his patients.

11/08/2025

Very personable. Answered all my questions.

11/06/2025

I already have referred several people.

10/20/2025

We have gone to Dr McMahon for over 20 years and have always liked his approach to our care!

10/14/2025

Dr. McMahon. He’s the reason. The best Dr I have ever had. Enough so that my son, daughter and husband now go to him as well. Get more Dr like him!! Patients want to be heard, not rushed through. He explains your problem. Explains the different drugs/treatments. HE TRULY CARES!!!!!!!

10/13/2025

He always takes the time to listen and he actually remembers some of our discussions that took place several months prior.

10/10/2025

Great Dr ! Spends time with U , answers ?

10/07/2025

I think they would benefit from the care and appreciate the service

10/06/2025

Friendly and professional.

10/04/2025

Very likable, experienced provider. Relates well to all patients.

09/27/2025

He’s very thorough in his examination, always takes time to listen and has been an incredible Doctor helping me manage and maintain my health.

09/27/2025

Great doctor

09/23/2025

Dr.McMAHON is an excellent physician.

09/22/2025

D. McMahon is extremely personable and takes the time to understand our concerns.

09/22/2025

Great Dr. listens to me.

09/22/2025

Listens to patient

09/19/2025

Dr. McMahon is caring, friendly, listens to you & makes you feel like you are an important part of the community. He spends time listening to you & helps you feel that your health is of utmost concern. Helps me focus on disease prevention & management of future years ahead.

09/18/2025

he easy to talk to,

09/08/2025

Dr. McMahon is an excellent care provider who listens to his patients, asks good questions and involves me in my care plan.

09/06/2025

I feel that he’s the best doctor in the world

08/30/2025

Always makes me feel heard. Easy to talk to.

08/25/2025

Great doctor.

08/25/2025

Best doctor and staff ever!

08/21/2025

Dr. McMahon is a caring professional. He does have his little quirks, but he’s a lot of fun too. He can tell if you’re in a difficult situation and will make you laugh, but he also listens to what’s bothering you and lets you lean on him to try to figure things out.

08/18/2025

He listens to what I have to say

08/11/2025

He's a great Doctor. Been with him since the beginning and dont see myself leaving. He takes the time to listen to each of his patients. Learn about them to give a better quality of care. Unlike others doctors just see you as revolving money bag

08/06/2025

He has always been friendly and professional. Listens to my health concerns. He makes recommendations based on my health results before they may become real issues.

08/05/2025

He is personable and it makes a huge difference knowing someone really cares about your health.

07/29/2025

Very engaging and had always listen to any issues that come up.

07/24/2025

Honest and kind individual who takes the time to make sure he understands my concerns and helps me to choose the best plan to address any concerns.

07/21/2025

Dr. Donald McMahon is the best doctor

07/21/2025

Dr. Donald McMahon is the best Doctor, he cares about his patients & listen to his patients

07/21/2025

I have been a patient of dr. McMahon for 30 years. And he is a wonderful dr.

07/15/2025

If time permits for the appointment, he and I I sing a song together and this helps me build my vocal chords back to a singing range tolerable for people to listen to.

07/10/2025

He listens attentively, answers questions thoughtfully and never makes me feel that he’s rushing to see his next patient.

07/10/2025

In my life now at 74 years old I have never had a better family Doctor than Dr Donald McMahon, he takes great care of me, and he takes the dread or going to the doctor.

07/05/2025

He’s a remarkable doctor I can’t say enough good about him .He always has time for you very sympathetic very knowledgeable I just hope and pray I never lose him as a doctor.

07/05/2025

Good Dr

07/03/2025

He is very kind and caring always professional always tries to help me feel better. I respect, and trust him very much. He is a great person.

07/03/2025

He’s a great doctor.

07/02/2025

Best Doctor ever!

06/24/2025

Has the ability to communicate in a way that is easy to understand and follow.

06/17/2025

He’s a good listener and communicator. If presented with a problem, he often offers more than one option as to how to solve it. Appointment never feels hurried.

06/09/2025

He is just amazing and genuinely cares about his patients

06/08/2025

Dr McMahon is caring and listens to patients concerns

06/02/2025

He’s the best!

05/28/2025

Down to earth person

05/26/2025

Exceptional doctor.

05/17/2025

I've been a patient of Dr McMahon's for over 20 years. He is by far the best Dr that I've ever had. He has made a tremendously positive impact in my life.

05/13/2025

Very friendly and knowledgeable.

05/13/2025

He is a good doctor and isn’t all about just prescribing stuff he will talk about options with you and explain outcomes

05/07/2025

Listens well; is very informative; takes time to discuss treatment

05/05/2025

Very wonderful!Caring and compassionate very good bed side manners.He is also very well educated.He cares about his patients.

05/05/2025

He’s the best doctor I’ve ever had he doesn’t make you feel like your bothering him I like his personality and that he remembers everything and treats me great

04/29/2025

Very thorough and communicates very well. Very engaged every time I'm there with him.

04/27/2025

Where can I go to the doctor and the doctor listens to your issues and helps you get answers to what is going on.

04/24/2025

Donald Elvis Mcmahon has been my Doctor for over 20 years if he ever leaves I leave

04/22/2025

He spends time listening to our concerns and doesn't rush us through the appointment.

04/21/2025

Takes time with his patients and listens

04/19/2025

Personable and cares

04/18/2025

Great Dr

04/16/2025

He has a doctor that cares

04/15/2025

He’s the best doctor. Personable and kind, never feels like he’s rushing to see his next patient. Listens and doesn’t judge.

04/10/2025

Friendly, efficient, caring, good listeners, accommodating and sometimes entertaining

04/07/2025

I like my dr and location

04/07/2025

Have you ever done an appointment with Doctor McMahon? You must check that off your bucket list!

04/01/2025

Dr. McMahon is a very knowledgeable doctor.

03/31/2025

He’s been a great doctor for me looks deeper into my condition and try to find the right solution for me and my health concerns
Show more

Hospitals