Dismiss Modal
Franciscan Health logo
Alicia H Ottenweller, NP-C

Alicia H Ottenweller, NP-C

Family Nurse Practitioner
Franciscan Physician Network
Languages Spoken
English

The tau symbol represents physicians who are employees of the Franciscan Physician Network, a division of Franciscan Alliance, Inc. All other physicians are independent members of the Medical Staff who choose to practice at a Franciscan Health hospital.

accepting new patients

Franciscan Physician Network CityWay Family Medicine

426 South Alabama Street
Suite 100
Indianapolis, IN 46225

View hours
Monday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Tuesday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Wednesday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Thursday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Friday
8:00am - 5:00pm
Franciscan Physician Network CityWay Family Medicine

Franciscan Health Indianapolis

8111 South Emerson Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46237

View hours
Sunday
Open 24 hours
Monday
Open 24 hours
Tuesday
Open 24 hours
Wednesday
Open 24 hours
Thursday
Open 24 hours
Friday
Open 24 hours
Saturday
Open 24 hours
Franciscan Health Indianapolis

About Me

Education

Nursing School:
The Ohio State University College of Nursing

Undergraduate:
University of Illinois at Chicago

Board Certifications

American Academy of Nurse Practitioners

Insurances Accepted

  • Aetna
  • Anthem
  • Anthem HIP
  • Anthem Medicaid
  • CareSource
  • Cofinity
  • Corvel
  • Department of Labor
  • Devoted Health
  • Encore Health Network
  • Humana
  • Humana Medicaid
  • Managed Health Services
  • Managed Health Services MarketPlace
  • Medicaid IN
  • Medicare IN
  • Medicare Rail Road
  • MultiPlan/PHCS
  • Sagamore
  • SIHO
  • Tricare/Humana Military
  • United Health Care
  • United Health Care Medicaid
Show more

Provider Ratings

5 out of 5

(149 ratings)

The Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to the care provider related questions shown below from our survey. Patients that are treated in outpatient or hospital environments may receive different surveys, and the volume of responses will vary by question.

88 Reviews

11/27/2025

She pays attention to me

11/18/2025

It is so easy to communicate with Alicia Ottenweller. She listens and answers our concerns

11/16/2025

SHE LISTENS!!!!! It has been a long time since I've been to a doctor, and I am sooooo happy that I now have Alecia Ottenweller! I now feel better than I have in a long, long time, thanks to her!

11/15/2025

She is competent and good at following up. Very prompt on answering messages and ordering tests.

11/12/2025

She is always thorough and anxious to get to the root cause of your condition. An amazing practitioner of health care.

11/09/2025

I was thinking about asking my son about seeking help there.

11/06/2025

Love how she listens and acts upon my symptoms

10/28/2025

Alicia has a professional manner, explains things and is open to any questions. She explained my blood results in an easy to understand manner. Refered to my previous visit to be sure all was well.

10/24/2025

Professional, listens before diagnosing

10/23/2025

Alicia is very friendly and empathetic.listen carefully and try to help to find out the root cause

10/22/2025

Alicia was so caring and attentive. She showed concern for my health and well being and assured me that she would work with me to provide the best possible care. She is a definite asset to Franciscan City Way and I am one lucky guy to have had her care.

10/20/2025

Polite Warm Welcoming Listens

10/15/2025

She’s very good at explaining what is happening. She’s a very good listener as well.

10/14/2025

She is an amazing woman who is the best doctor that I have had.

10/08/2025

Very professional and good listener to my health issues

10/02/2025

Kind, caring, patient, listens, responsive, knowledgeable…

09/27/2025

Alicia takes the time to ask me questions about my symptoms and lifestyle to make sure all my needs are addressed.

09/25/2025

Alicia has been easy to work with, and easy to talk to. She’s very knowledgeable, she asks questions, and offers to help me any way she can. I also like that for my quarterly check-in appointments, she uses telehealth so I don’t have to take time off at work.

09/17/2025

I really enjoy Alicia Ottenweller. She is more thorough than most the doctors I have seen.

09/17/2025

Alicia Ottenweller is awesome she listens and always offering suggestions to get and be healthier

09/17/2025

She is great!

09/13/2025

She is just perfect for me. Takes things slow, a step at a time. I come home feeling more relaxed.

09/10/2025

She explained everything so clearly and answered all my questions.

09/06/2025

Very knowledgeable, easy to communicate with, keeps me posted on changes, very familiar with my situation, eager to find the answers if she doesn't already have them, etc.

08/29/2025

Very good

08/27/2025

I was treated in a friendly and relaxed environment

08/21/2025

She is an awesome doctor.

08/20/2025

Because she was able to ask me some basic questions that make me feel she knows what really is doing

08/19/2025

Is kind and compassionate, always asks the right questions, is available to answer any questions I have. Really listens and is quick to action.

08/12/2025

She listens, is reassuring, pleasant, and knowledgeable!

08/11/2025

Saved my life

08/05/2025

See above comments- she’s fabulous

08/03/2025

Alicia is thorough, she listens, she makes patients feel seen and validates them when there are issues that are not immediately resolved

07/29/2025

The follow up response is impeccable! The doctor ensures that she follows up if there is an unanswered question during the visit, the doctor responds within 24 hours

07/23/2025

Alicia listens closely and remembers my past problems!!! She takes me seriously!!!

07/20/2025

Always takes the time to ensure my needs are met. Super knowledgeable. Makes decisions jointly with me.

07/18/2025

Because just I stated, She respects my wishes, and has patience for the slow minded, I wish to her to be my P.M. Provider from here on our Sincerely, And I hope she is made aware of how grateful I am..

07/16/2025

She listened to me.

07/12/2025

Good doctor to speak too

07/12/2025

She is a brilliant diagnostician. Her bedside manners are superb. She is caring and listens. She always exceeds my expectations!

07/11/2025

Alicia Ottenweller is always listening and really good with suggestions in moving forward, rather it be diet, health or excercise

07/08/2025

She listens, is patient, reassuring. I wish I had found her years ago

07/02/2025

She’s been good to me and helping me get back together

06/19/2025

Very thorough

06/04/2025

So nice - always!

06/03/2025

Alicia Ottenweller is a high level practitioner, I want others to experience the wonderful reassurance of good health goals and objectives she sets forth for her patients. She lets you know that if anything transpires between the next scheduled visit that she is there for you.

06/03/2025

Alicia is always very understanding and helpful during my appointments. She is very thorough and consistent when it comes to my health.

06/02/2025

She quickly assessed my health situation and helped me determine how much I should be concerned about how serious the condition was. She gave good advice, so I was able to take the next steps in my care confidently.

05/29/2025

I didn’t feel rushed. I thought Alicia heard and addressed my concerns.

05/21/2025

She just was very open, easy and patient and made me feel at ease as I can be.

05/14/2025

She will discuss things in as much detailed as needed and that helps my nerves with doctor appointments in general

05/12/2025

Yes, me and my boyfriend are thinking about turning her into my family doctor

05/07/2025

Pleasant person

04/30/2025

As a part of getting up to speed on my medical history, she was very thorough in her questions. Additionally, she was very thoughtful in her answers to my questions/concerns about the reason for my visit. Thank you.

04/29/2025

She makes you feel at ease and listens and truly cares

04/28/2025

She always takes her time to throughly address and explain things. She has personally called to deliver test results when it was a critical situation. While I was stressed, she was calming and kept a professional and caring tone. Highly recommend her.

04/25/2025

Very kind and answered all my questions, I didn't feel rushed by her and I hope I can see her forever!

04/24/2025

She has been extremely helpful with my medical needs. She listens, is knowledgeable, and compassionate!

04/21/2025

She listens to you and it feels like we are a partner in my health rather than being told what to do.

04/15/2025

Alicia O. is always listening and always offering to assist with any medical issues you may have.

04/11/2025

She has a very conscientious manner with her clients. I was there mere days after being released from the hospital, for A-Fib and a second stroke she raises the broader questions about my health. Alicia Ottenweller is an excellent listener, is focused on healing, dignity, respect and challenges me to seek the higher grounds in my choices for a great quality of life, diet and exercise commiting myself to exellence.

04/07/2025

Dr. Ottenweller is always Friendly and open to my ideas. She hugged me when I begged her not to give up on me, like my other Dr's.

03/27/2025

Alicia was attentive to listen to what issues I have, and very thorough with helping me know what was available for help.

03/16/2025

She's very friendly and professional.

03/14/2025

She was very attentive and listened to my concerns.

03/12/2025

She is a nice lady and she knows what she is doing

03/10/2025

Great job listening Very nice

03/06/2025

Alicia is fantastic. Very personable and willing to take time to talk to me as a patient. Additionally, she seems very knowledgeable. Would highly recommend.

03/01/2025

She really listens to what you're saying. She is definitely my favorite health care provider.

02/27/2025

She is a very nice and kind-hearted person. Who really cares about her patience

02/24/2025

great communication and wonderful ‘bedside’ manner

02/06/2025

Fatima & Alicia were professional & friendly. It was scary for me to meet & go over my entire history. I am sure as we proceed with more visits the score will just get higher.

02/04/2025

She is always concerned and helpful. I have many health problems.

01/28/2025

Office manager was able to get me into my specialty appointment super quick. Alicia always listens to my needs and concerns. She’s quick to get answers for you. Front office ladies are wonderful and medical assistant today was super sweet! They both asked me if I’d mind if the new NP came in without just assuming I’d be okay. I appreciated that.

01/28/2025

She know what she doing, she was extremely patient with me, she gave me good advice to recover quickly

01/16/2025

Alicia is kind, knowledgeable and extremely helpful. I don’t have any cons that I can think of

01/15/2025

Very professional experience. Very detailed service.

01/14/2025

She was very attentive and made sure that I was happy with the testing/treatment plan.

01/13/2025

My doctor really listens to my concerns, and does her best to treat, diagnose, or care for any issue I bring up. Rare occurrence these days.

01/03/2025

She is very polite, professional, and genuinely caring.

12/16/2024

She was excellent.

12/12/2024

She was very welcoming and professional! She asked questions before I could ask them that was on the top of my mind! She recommended things I would have never thought of! Very knowledgeable as well!

12/12/2024

Security be time dealing with Alicia on kinda an emergency basis and I love her so much that I am making her my family doctor from now on

12/11/2024

She was so kind to me. She showed great sympathy for my struggles

12/11/2024

Very thorough and detailed as she did a fantastic job in explaining my symptoms to me. Thank you!

12/09/2024

She was friendly and knowledgeable, very professional

12/09/2024

She was very knowledgeable and friendly and was down to earth. I really like her.

12/07/2024

Alicia is wonderful to work with. She always takes the time to listen completely and not rush.
Show more

Hospitals